Hot Topics

ATEB has completed a number of Section 166 Skilled Persons reviews - here are some of the lessons learnt.

MiFID II PROD rules require firms to ensure products and funds are matched to the the right 'target market' clients.

Senior Managers & Certification Regime will apply to all FCA regulated firms from 9 December 2019 - are you ready?

Firms that deal with a DFM on an agent as client basis could be exposed to hidden risks.

Many providers, platforms and adviser firms are not yet properly compliant with the aggregated costs disclosure requirements.

Many cash flow models are not compliant with FCA rules on growth assumptions. Are yours?

Firms that advise on DB transfers need a process for assessing Transfer Risk.

Many firms have not amended their status disclosure to reflect the MiFIDII definition of independence.

Suitability reports under MiFID II

Wednesday, October 18, 2017

MiFID II, which comes into effect from 3 January 2018 covers a lot of ground and will require many firms to make changes to advice processes. Suitability reports are one important aspect that many firms will have to reconsider under MiFID II.

ATEB's intelligent Suitability software is designed to help firms deliver effective suitability reports with minimum effort, enabling both the initial and ongoing reporting required under MiFID II.

Timing of suitability reports

Under MiFID II, a suitability report will have to be issued 'before the conclusion of any contract' recommended in it. There is some debate to be had around when a contract is concluded but we believe this simply means pre-sale - or that, in practice, firms should consider that to be a safe way to comply with the rule. We take the view that providing the report to clients before they make a decision on how to proceed has always been good practice and places the client in the best position to make an informed decision.

Content of suitability reports

Suitability reports must specify the advice given and how that advice meets the preferences, objectives and other characteristics of the client. COBS 9, the current primary source of rules and guidance on suitability will remain in place after 3 January 2018, at least for while but there is a whole new chapter, COBS 9A that will also apply to most firms and contains a few new requirements.

Firms must inform clients or potential clients, clearly and simply, that the reason for assessing suitability is to enable the firm to act in the client’s best interest.

When recommending a ‘bundled package’ of products, firms need to ensure that the overall package is suitable. For example, an investment linked to borrowing (lifetime mortgage or equity release type arrangements).

Records relating to suitability in respect of a life policy, a personal pension or a stakeholder plan where a client proceeds with the recommendation must be retained for a minimum of 5 years. Records relating to pension transfers, conversions and opt-outs still have indefinite retention. Records relating to suitability where a client does not proceed with the recommendation do not need to be retained but we would recommend that they are kept as long as they might be of value. 

Periodic assessment of suitability

This is a new requirement and firms will need to give serious consideration to how their ongoing service propositions operate. Periodic assessment of suitability is detailed in COBS 9A.

"Firms providing investment advice must agree with a client whether a periodic assessment of suitability will be performed. If periodic assessment is to be performed it must be at least annually and the continued suitability confirmed in writing."

Most firms currently agree with the client whether ongoing reviews are required or not. Where ongoing service is to be provided, it is usually at least annually. So far so good, no fundamental changes of practice required by most if not all firms.

However, while we believe firms probably provide written confirmation of any changes to be made to the client's portfolio, it is less certain that there would always be written confirmation of the suitability of existing investments each time, if otherwise no changes or new investments are being made. So, firms should note that there will need to be explicit confirmation of the suitability of existing investments each time a review is done and that such reviews must be at least annual.

The periodic report, must contain an updated statement of how the existing investments meet the preferences, objectives and other characteristics of the client. But such confirmation of continued suitability does not need to be War and Peace – a reference back to original report and brief confirmation is all that is required. The rules state -

“Where an investment firm provides a service that involves periodic suitability assessments and reports, the subsequent reports after the initial service is established may only cover changes in the services or instruments involved and/or the circumstances of the client and may not need to repeat all the details of the first report.”



Our View

Suitability requirements remain essentially the same under MiFID II as at present. However, the aspects mentioned in this article are likely to need firms to reconsider and amend some aspects of how suitability is assessed and documented, both initially and on an ongoing basis.

Ongoing review services will need to be re-assessed and, in many cases, reinvented. 

These are just the tip of the MiFID II iceberg of things that will have an impact on firms and that will need to be addressed in the run up to 3 January 2018. That is really not far away so we would encourage early attention to MiFID II. ATEB can support firms with accurate information and with the implementation of MiFID II ready processes.

In particular, Suitability, ATEB's intelligent suitability software is designed to help firms deliver effective suitability reports with minimum effort and supports both initial and ongoing reporting to clients.

Action Required By You

  • Give early attention to how MiFID II affects your firm;
  • Consider whether ATEB's Suitability software could help deliver on the new requirements for suitability reports and periodic assessment of suitability;
  • Speak to your usual ATEB Consultant to see how we can help you prepare for MiFID II or contact us here;
  • Click here for more information on Suitability;
  • Don't delay, MiFID II is not far away!